It is still
almost 4 weeks until Arsenal take on Manchester
City at Wembley in the
semi final of the FA Cup. The match will be the 16th and penultimate
stop on The Road to Wembley from Scotland . Regular readers will know
that it is usually at about this time in the build to the match that I explore
the Scottish connections of my ‘new’ team. I have previously reported on
Arsenal’s strong links with Bella Caledonia and I can now also state that Manchester City too have a rich Scots heritage. In
their ’50 top City players of all time list’ there are 4 Scots listed – namely
Dave Ewing, Willie Donnachie, Denis Law and Asa Hartford. Also worthy of
special mention is the journeyman player but cult hero Andy Morrison.
Dave Ewing
from Perthshire played for City for a full decade between 1952 and 1962 making 279
appearances and scoring one goal. The uncompromising defender was one Scotsman
who did not need to wear a ginger wig as he sported a striking shock of red
hair.
No ginger wig needed. FA Cup winner red haired Dave Ewing City stalwart in the 50s |
Dave was
selected mostly at centre half and is remembered for his vocal encouragement to
team mates and was regarded as a tough tackler. He played in two FA Cup finals
in the mid fifties and claimed an FA Cup winners medal when City beat Birmingham 3-1 in the
final best remembered as the final where City goalkeeper Bert Trautmann broke
his neck. With no substitutes allowed in those days Trautmann played on and
ended up on the winning team! At the end of this playing days Ewing moved into
coaching and after being employed as a coach at Sheffield Wednesday, Bradford City
and Crystal Palace he was appointed manager of Hibs
for the 1970-71 season. His spell at Easter Road was not successful and he
returned to his first love, Manchester
City , to manage the
reserve team. He is credited with overseeing the development of many promising
City youngsters who subsequently progressed to the first team. Dave settled in
Lancashire and later the ginger haired Ewing
owned a hardware store in the appropriately named town Reddish. Dave Ewing
sadly passed away in 1999 at the age of 70.
Glaswegian
Willie Donnachie served Man
City with great
distinction throughout the 1970s. He played for City 351 times and the full
back scored two goals. In 1976 he helped Man
City win the League Cup and this was
his only medal while playing for Man
City .
Willie Donnachie: Maine Road hero of the seventies |
Donnachie
was something of a fitness fanatic and his regime helped him to play
professional football until the age of 39. After leaving City in 1980 at the
age of 29 he had a spell in US
soccer with Portland Timbers and then spells with Norwich
City and Burnley .
Then in 1984 he signed for Oldham Athletic and went on to play for them for the
next six years. Donnachie also played 35 times for Scotland and although he had
some great games in famous dark blue jersey he is best remembered for scoring a
calamitous own goal in a match against Wales. Donnachie is now 65 years old and
having worked as a coach for Newcastle United from 2011-14 he has settled in
the north east of England .
When I went
through the list of the ’50 greatest ever City players’ I was very surprised to
find the name of Denis Law. The Lawman was certainly a Rolls-Royce of a
footballer but the Aberdonian is much better known for his playing days at
Manchester United where he helped the Red Devils win the European Cup in 1968. Law
played for Man City as a youngster in the 1960-61
season and then as a veteran in the 1973-74 season. In total he played 68 times
for City and scored 30 goals. In between times he played for the great
Manchester United team of the 1960s and was part of the Best, Law and Charlton
triumvirate. His most famous goal for City was when he scored a cheeky back
heel in the final league game of the 73-74 season – against Manchester United.
The goal has achieved notoriety because Law refused to celebrate and because
the impudent strike was instrumental in confirming Manchester United’s
relegation to Division Two.
Oh no I have scored! Denis Law (no 10) scores 'that goal' for City against United |
Denis Law
to this day still regrets scoring that goal against Manchester United. When
interviewed by the Scotsman two years ago he said “I just felt depressed, and that wasn’t like me. After 19 years of
trying my hardest to score goals, here was one that I almost wished hadn’t
actually gone in. I was inconsolable. I didn’t want it to happen. How long did
the feeling last? How long ago was the game? Thirty-odd years. There is your
answer. The subject always crops up. It’s one of those things. It’s always
there and I am always remembered for it. That’s a shame.”
A distraught Law is consoled by his City team mates after scoring 'that goal' |
As well as
representing both Manchester clubs Law also
played for Scotland
on 55 occasions and scored 30 goals for the national team. Still going strong
at the age of 77 the Lawman was awarded the CBE last year and this year is to
receive the ‘Freedom of the City of Aberdeen ’.
Asa
Hartford is a Glaswegian former midfielder who built his reputation as a
talented youngster with West Bromwich Albion. After making his debut for the
Baggies in 1967 he progressed well and his progress was noted by the all
conquering Leeds United who moved to sign him in a high profile transfer in
November 1971. The deal was all but done when it was discovered during the
medical that he had a heart condition that was described at the time as a ‘hole
in the heart’. He returned to West Brom where
he continued to play at a high level. One night on Match of the Day commentator
David Coleman, noted as the inspiration for Colemanballs, blurted “this lad was
diagnosed with a hole in the heart but the way he is playing today you can see
he is a whole-hearted player!”. Asa’s dream move to a top team did come along
eventually when Manchester
City signed him in 1974
Scots City legend Asa Hartford: A whole-hearted player! |
In his
first spell at Maine Road Asa Hartford played 185 times for City scoring 22
goals. He also helped Man
City win the League Cup
in 1976. In 1979 he moved on to Nottingham
Forest and then on to
Everton. He returned to Man
City in 1981 and played
for City for a further 3 years and added another 75 appearances and 7 goals to
his tallies. When in his prime Asa was capped by Scotland on 50 occasions scoring 5
goals for the national team. He continued playing into forties turning out for Norwich City ,
Bolton Wanderers, Stockport County , Oldham Athletic and Shrewsbury in his dotage. An impressively
long career for a man with an alleged heart defect. Asa Hartford is now 66
years old and is still gainfully employed in football as he provides scouting
services for Norwich
City .
My final
homage to famous Scots who have worn the sky blue colours is to Andy Morrison.
Andy is a favourite of the Scots
Man City
twitter feed @thegingerwigmcfc. Unlike the other ‘legends’ quoted in this post,
highlander Morrison was not capped by Scotland . In fact the rugged
defender spent most of his career in the lower echelons of English football.
Good, Mad, Ugly and Fat! Cult hero Andy Morrison |
When Man City
were languishing in the third tier of English football, Morrison was the
captain who steered them back towards respectability. He was the rock at the
heart of the defence when Man
City were promoted back
to the second tier in 1999. His cult status with the City faithful owes much to
his determination, will to win and his eccentric aggressive style of play. My
beloved Hearts could do with an Andy Morrison in their team right now! Madman
Morrison is now 46 years old and is the manager of Welsh Premier League team
Connahs Quay. He combines that role with his duties as an official fan
ambassador at Manchester
City .
There are
no doubt other Scots who are fondly remembered by the City fans and I may well
update this ‘City Scots’ post later in the blog. For now I need to turn my
attention back to trying to get a ticket for the FA Cup semi final between City
and Arsenal. I still don’t have a ticket yet. I have a number of feelers out
and a number of pals are making enquiries on my behalf. Hence, at this stage, I
am still holding off paying out an inflated price to one of the dodgy ticket
web sites.
I note also
this week that Arsene Wenger continues to attract negative coverage from the
media. Despite this the Professor is hanging on in there as manager of Arsenal.
This weekend the Gunners take on City in a Premier League match that will also
serve as a dress rehearsal for their meeting in the FA Cup semi final. I will
be back later in the week with some of the build up to that match and also with
an update on the plight of my old pal Arsene. Who knows, I may also have news
on a ticket for the semi final when I post later this week. Come back here for
more just before the weekend .. and … keep reading.